Patrons Official Movie Review: LoTR Trilogy

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 4
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous 1 2 3 4 template Next
  • lopxtc
    Unix Geek
    • Oct 2001
    • 2706
    #46
    Sorry my friend you are wrong ...

    (enter_geek_mode)

    In appendix B ... under SR (Shire Reconning) 1482, it is said that shortly after Rose dies, Sam leaves the shire and then sails to the Grey Havens. He passes the red book onto Elanor and then passes the towers to depart out to the Grey Havens.

    Its under the later events of the members of the fellowship heading.

    (exit_geek_mode)

    Aaron
    Team Managed Aggression, Missouri Paintball

    Pround owner of a 2003 Shocker, and AO.org user ... an almost unheard of combo.
    "Love, Peace, and Shonen Knife!"
    AOLIM - lopxtc

      Comment

      • 1stdeadeye
        Still around????
        • Jun 2002
        • 8501
        #47
        Originally posted by lopxtc
        Sorry my friend you are wrong ...

        (enter_geek_mode)

        In appendix B ... under SR (Shire Reconning) 1482, it is said that shortly after Rose dies, Sam leaves the shire and then sails to the Grey Havens. He passes the red book onto Elanor and then passes the towers to depart out to the Grey Havens.

        Its under the later events of the members of the fellowship heading.

        (exit_geek_mode)

        Aaron
        Okay that's fine. I just knew he did not leave for the Greyhavens with Frodo and the others. Maybe he was told that though a ring bearer for a short while, now was not his time?

        I'll have to break out my copy. and read the end again. It has been a long time!

          Comment

          • lopxtc
            Unix Geek
            • Oct 2001
            • 2706
            #48
            Yes he was told that he did need to say behind to continue on with the shire ...

            Legolas and Gimili eventually leave for the Grey Havens also ... this doesnt occur till the last event. Pipin and Merry eventually spend their last days in Gondor and are both laid to rest in the halls of the Great King.

            Aaron

            Originally posted by 1stdeadeye


            Okay that's fine. I just knew he did not leave for the Greyhavens with Frodo and the others. Maybe he was told that though a ring bearer for a short while, now was not his time?

            I'll have to break out my copy. and read the end again. It has been a long time!
            Team Managed Aggression, Missouri Paintball

            Pround owner of a 2003 Shocker, and AO.org user ... an almost unheard of combo.
            "Love, Peace, and Shonen Knife!"
            AOLIM - lopxtc

              Comment

              • Fred
                AO Zealot
                • Feb 2002
                • 2624
                #49
                Legolas and Gimli go, Legolas because he's an Elf and Gimli because their friendship was so great. They don't leave until after Aragorn and Arwen die though.

                Sam goes after Rosie dies.

                Merry, being a knight of the Mark, returns there when Eomer dies, and Pippin goes to Gondor... both die of old age, at least one of them is entombed near Aragorn (but they both died before i think).

                Arwen dies after Aragorn in LothLorien...

                Its been a few months since i read the Appendices in depth... time to go into geek mode myself... :)
                Warp Feed Evangelist
                My Feedback

                  Comment

                  • lopxtc
                    Unix Geek
                    • Oct 2001
                    • 2706
                    #50
                    Neither Merry or Pipin goto the Grey Havens ...

                    SR 1541 -- "In this year on March 1st came at last the passing of King Elessar. It is said that the beds of Mariadoc and Peregrin were set aside the bed of the great king."

                    Aaron

                    Originally posted by Fred
                    Merry, being a knight of the Mark, returns there when Eomer dies, and Pippin goes to Gondor... both die of old age, at least one of them is entombed near Aragorn (but they both died before i think).
                    Team Managed Aggression, Missouri Paintball

                    Pround owner of a 2003 Shocker, and AO.org user ... an almost unheard of combo.
                    "Love, Peace, and Shonen Knife!"
                    AOLIM - lopxtc

                      Comment

                      • phantomhitman
                        ao's official bad guy
                        • Oct 2003
                        • 1841
                        #51
                        well, i loved the triogy. first movie was great, second was incredible, and the third was great. there was way too much going on to be told in 3 hours.
                        they should have ended the movie as soon as the ring was destroyed i guess
                        my feedback
                        countdown on devilmag day........ill let you now

                          Comment

                          • Patron God of Pirates
                            ~pgop1.0
                            • Apr 2002
                            • 1196
                            #52
                            Is there a rule against necroposting my own thread?

                            Friendly corner used to rule. I'd love to know where all these cats are.

                              Comment

                              • wetwrks
                                Splatting since '85

                                • Jun 2007
                                • 1828
                                #53
                                Originally posted by pgop2.0
                                Is there a rule against necroposting my own thread?

                                Friendly corner used to rule. I'd love to know where all these cats are.


                                  Comment

                                  Previous 1 2 3 4 template Next
                                  Working...