PDA

View Full Version : OK, I'm at a dead end



BTAutoMag
04-10-2013, 09:17 PM
My mag wont stop breaking paint!:mad:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYwzOFc07E8

here's the setup and ive clearanced the carbon fiber and got a new prophecy loader thats set up on its highest speed.

the body is heavily modified and ive noticed a couple sharp spots that have been polished and smoothed over.

switched to a larger bore barrel retuned the lvl 10... twice... but at this point im open to anything:confused:



EDIT: after the video, a good cleaning and a new hopper with fresh batteries I tried again. 3 balls broke in a row and then I had bolt stick... when i say bolt stick... the bolt was all the way FORWARD!

OPBN
04-10-2013, 09:22 PM
Check to make sure your detent isn't in too far.

captian pinky
04-10-2013, 09:24 PM
if you are having bolt stick it is either your ball detent is in to far or your lvl10 is not tuned correctly. is your spring extending past the face of the bolt?

zondo
04-10-2013, 09:34 PM
if you are having bolt stick it is either your ball detent is in to far or your lvl10 is not tuned correctly. is your spring extending past the face of the bolt?

Seconded... Start with the level 10 then work on the detent.

sQuidvision
04-10-2013, 10:30 PM
cant help but notice all the snow... is it perhaps cold? Cold marker? Cold paint?

EDIT: Just read about your bold being stuck FORWARD... probably not cold related lol.

Cokrkilr
04-11-2013, 12:32 AM
What spring is in the lvl 10?

Only reason I ask is the stock gold spring can still produce chops. It hits quite a bit harder than the red, I've stuck my pinky in both and it was very significant between the two springs.

Nobody
04-11-2013, 01:20 AM
posting before watching the vid
1) ditch the hopper and hand feed. eliminate the possibility of the hopper breaking the paint BEFORE getting into the breech.
2) where is the paint breaking? if its in the breech, then its the gun. if its in the barrel, then its in the barrel.
3) if the bolt is sticking forward, then its being hung up on something. if not the ball detent, then look at the feedneck. it might be sticking in and catching the bolt. examine it to see if there are marks on the bolt.

after watching the vid
4) check the length of the trigger rod.
5) check the length of the on/off rod.
6) make sure that the powertube is screwed down all the way, so that the bolt is coming to rest, where it should be and not being pushed forward a little bit.
7) are the screws holding the gun together, in snuggly?
8) have you tried eliminating the other parts of the gun, i.e. changing the body, frame, or valve to see if its one specific part that's giving you trouble?

it doesn't hurt to step back and examine the gun with the eye. mags are simple in design and implementation. there is a certain symbiosis of the parts. granted, you've modded just about everything, so it could be anything. one part, one oring could throw everything out of balance, or it could be a mass of everything not being in sync with each other. it might be a feng shui thing, but if you understand how the parts work together, it helps figuring out how the gun works and why its doing what it is.

side note- unless you have an expensive gauge where its calibrated to a certain +/-, gauges will more than likely be wrong. it could be off 1%, which at 800psi, could be actually 790psi or 810psi. if its worse, like 10%, that 800 gauge could be as high as 900psi, or as low as 700psi. i never trust gauges and only use them as a general way to get into the ballpark and see what the gun likes.

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 07:48 AM
OPBN- Detent is PROBABLY not the issue I have checked and rechecked clearance on it.

captian pinky- Medium spring, about 1/2 -5/8" past face of bolt

sQuidvision- was outside for about 5 min, temp was 45*

Cokrkilr- I'll try that today

Nobody- ball frag got stuck inbetween bolt and body, nothing detent related, have checked clearance.
I'll try hand feeding, its breaking in breach
trigger rod is set about 1/16th behind trigger gassed up. running a ULT with 2 shims
yes and yes
I dont have another body unless i go to twistlock.

OPBN
04-11-2013, 08:18 AM
Pull the detent out and dry fire. Do you still get the bolt sticking forward? There are two o-rings that come with the detents. One is thinner than the other. It doesnt take much to cause issues.

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 08:26 AM
its a stock angel detent. I had to go buy an oring to space it right. that bolt stck cause of broken paint

OPBN
04-11-2013, 08:36 AM
Are you using crappy paint? Is it possible the paint is very small and pushing past the detent causing double feeding issues?

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 08:44 AM
Graffiti. same paint i put through everything else

Hook
04-11-2013, 09:02 AM
Valken Graffiti is amazing paint, but breaks real easily. Then again, I've never had any issues using that in my Mags. As for cold weather, that shouldn't affect the performances at all. I've played all winter long with my mags with no ill effect.

Also, like Nobody said, have you tried eliminating the other parts of the gun, i.e. changing the body, frame, or valve to see if its one specific part that's giving you trouble?

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 09:25 AM
like Nobody said

:rofl:

I'll give everything a shot tonight:shooting:

BigEvil
04-11-2013, 09:49 AM
Sorry I missed this one.. just watched the vid... those "efficiency mod" really arent a good idea on anything other than a 12gram powered pump.. and even then they are questionable. AGD made the dump chamber the size it is for a reason. By reducing it, you need to increase the pressure in it to move the bolt and fire the ball because you have decreased volume. A.I.R. valves were like that a while back and AGD figured out that it was causing a lot of ball breaks. They then increased the dump chamber size.

First thing I would try other than new paint and making sure your bolt spring is good would be to remove that efficiency mod....

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 09:52 AM
hmmm. thanks Big-E

I'll give that a shot!

Justus
04-11-2013, 09:56 AM
I also noticed after watching the video, that you mentioned the X-valve has an efficiency insert. A side effect of the higher efficiency is that the pressure is higher on the ball - it's harder on paint. If you're using very brittle paint, and it has cooled down to 45*, and you're using a forcefeed loader coupled with an efficiency insert-mod X-valve, that might just be your soupy combination.


EDIT: BigE beat me to it while I was watching and reading. lol

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 10:00 AM
then you fail:p

Spider-TW
04-11-2013, 10:26 AM
On top of the efficiency mod, the short barrel brings your ball pressure up also (for the same velocity). Do you have your foamy in place? It helps space the ball off the face of the bolt. Just between the efficiency mod and the short barrel, you are pushing the limits. Throw some weak paint in there and you have trouble.

My son pops one or two weak balls per day with a pump mag and an old minimag shorty barrel and no foamy. He shoots so fast it's hard to tell if he's tripping over the ball drop or blowing them up, but the problem seems to have doubled since he went to the short barrel. The efficiency mod (like flyingpootang's washers) was good with CO2 (and 300 fps), but we could crank the regulator up to leaking before hitting 280 fps with air. Since he needed quick and reliable refills for pump tournaments, we pulled out the washers and went back to full time air.

I know a longer barrel will get me 30 fps on some of my markers, and a heavily devolumized chamber is worth about 30 fps also. Either one is significant, together is probably too much.

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 10:36 AM
i also tried it with my 14 assasin barrel. the shortie is a freak barrel if that makes a difference to you

Coralis
04-11-2013, 10:41 AM
If all else fails try changing the frame , I chop paint like a mofo when using a two finger trigger . I guess i just fat finger it too much causing short stroke chopping, hopefully you don't have this affliction too.

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 10:45 AM
that frame is the reason I built this gun:mad:

Spider-TW
04-11-2013, 10:45 AM
i also tried it with my 14 assasin barrel. the shortie is a freak barrel if that makes a difference to you

Were you able to check the velocity with the longer barrel? I guess another test would be to turn the velocity down to something relatively low and see how the breaks go. That might help narrow it down between popping balls on air pressure or some other form of abuse.

BTAutoMag
04-11-2013, 10:54 AM
im grabbing a chrono tonight

bbotts77
04-11-2013, 11:00 AM
I would also recommend hand-feeding it or putting a shake and bake on it. I had the same problem when I was putting brittle paint through a prophecy that was turned up all the way. After I turned the speed down, it stopped breaking paint.

livebrando
04-11-2013, 11:42 AM
2 weekends ago my bolt stick was due to detent. You never know.

blackdeath1k
04-11-2013, 12:25 PM
My rt with a 12 year old wire v nubbin worked fine with my agitator. When I put my new halo 2 on it I had a bad double feeding issue due to the loader forcing paint past the nubbin. New style plastic nubbin and all issues were gone. That was with the halo in factory settings. With that loader on its fastest feed rate I would deff throw an old agitator loader or something on there to take that force feed out of the equation. And then it could just be a bad batch of paint and your hunting for a problem that isn't even gun related.

athomas
04-12-2013, 06:41 AM
The detents are easy to check. All you need to do is look at the breach area where they screw into the body. If any of the screw edge is felt inside the body, then the detents are in too far. Only the ball detent should be protruding into the breach.

As mentioned, the efficiency mod could be your problem. A regular level 10 bolt setup requires about 500 psi or more in the chamber to work at the desired velocity. If you use a shorter barrel, that pressure would be higher. When you reduce the chamber volume, you increase the pressure requirement. I don't know the pressure numbers on these, but I'm betting your chamber pressure is probably up around 650 psi or higher. That would require about 850psi or higher coming into the valve. You are showing 800psi on the gauge, but it could be even lower at 700 or 750psi given the error on these things. The lower the differences between the input and chamber, the less likely you are going to get a good seal at the valve orings. If these orings do not seal, then the bolt sticks forward. Rapid firing makes it worst, because the lower pressure differential reduces the flow rate and further accentuates the problem.

The other thing you might want to look at is the alignment of the valve with the body. Check for rub marks inside the breach area or where the bolt goes through the body washer. Is that washer flush or flat so the bolt spring can't bind or twist on the bolt inside the body?

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 07:47 AM
The detents are easy to check. All you need to do is look at the breach area where they screw into the body. If any of the screw edge is felt inside the body, then the detents are in too far. Only the ball detent should be protruding into the breach.


first thing I checked


If these orings do not seal, then the bolt sticks forward.


when I took the valve out... the bolt was still forward.


The other thing you might want to look at is the alignment of the valve with the body. Check for rub marks inside the breach area or where the bolt goes through the body washer. Is that washer flush or flat so the bolt spring can't bind or twist on the bolt inside the body?


its good

captian pinky
04-12-2013, 09:33 AM
what spring are you using. if i remember correctly you are supposed to use the red spring with the inserts.

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 09:38 AM
medium spring, but will change it to red and test

Justus
04-12-2013, 01:13 PM
I thought the red spring was the medium spring?

Gold/black = shortest, the "God" spring because it works
Red = medium, best for drop-in use with L10 bolts
Custom-trimmed Silver = long spring, needs to be custom trimmed for maximum softness of the L10 bolt

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 02:16 PM
sometimes I'm an idiot...

i thought the cut spring was only in the old kits:confused:

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 04:21 PM
I may have missplaced my red spring... I could be wrong. Are you sure its red and not clear or invisible? Lol

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 06:20 PM
Ok apparently I SUCK at tuning lvl 10s.

I have the long spring and the short spring, tried both. broke balls.

THEN!

I eliminated all variables and held the ball half way in the chamber and shot.

it broke with ALL the following combos:

-long spring, xvalve, eff mod
-short spring, xvalve, eff mod
-long spring, xvalve, no eff
-short spring xvalve, no eff
-short spring, classic, eff mod
-long spring, classic, eff mod
-short pring, classic, no eff
-long spring, classic, no eff

...

then I put everything in my backup mag that has benchy 2x, AM rail, AM body, crownpoint barrel and tried the same list with same results.

I followed the lvl 10 setup to the letter:mad: with both kits i have


but i did learn how to do a really neat trick
http://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s177/chromebeast/Paintball/20130412_171851_zps4dddf87d.jpg


Im so sick of cleaning barrels

BTAutoMag
04-12-2013, 07:56 PM
I'm thinking I might be shooting hot. im picking up a chrono tomorrow from the field to see.

maniacmechanic
04-12-2013, 09:06 PM
Once up on a time I found a bad LX bolt , the problem was the hole thru the center of the bolt was not drilled all the way down to intersect with the side vent hole , Does it vent when it hits the ball ?

captian pinky
04-12-2013, 11:44 PM
Are you using the largest carrier before it leaks down the barrel with out shooting?

Cokrkilr
04-13-2013, 02:23 AM
Id agree with the carrier size... my bolt sits so loose I expect it to leak every time I air it up, but it doesnt.

does the lvl 10 work on something other than paint? say for instance your tongue :rofl:

No but really, how hard of a "hit" does the bolt give a swab thats a little bit away from the bolt face? I can just stuff the swab down the barrel up to the bolt face in mine and shoot and it takes 5-6 shots to even move it enough to do a full fire.

athomas
04-13-2013, 09:27 AM
If you are making sure the ball is in the breach when firing, then it isn't chopping, which is what the level 10 is designed to prevent. It sounds like it is breaking balls when firing, which is a totally different problem. The bolt is getting up to full speed and force when you are getting your breaks, which indicates that it may be barrel related.

Ball breaks other than chops are caused by different scenarios such as:

1) the ball rolling forward too far which allows the bolt to slam into it at full force
2) the barrel being too tight for the paint being used
3) a detent sticking too far into the breach or perhaps broken and tearing the ball

How brittle is your paint? How large or small is your paint? Is it small enough to fit the barrel without any force?

captian pinky
04-13-2013, 10:04 AM
I've also heard of issues where people who don't have the goalie on there bolt where paint is rolling back a bit and the next ball comes partially in the breach. With the force of the hopper it may be to much causing the ball to break.

BTAutoMag
04-13-2013, 10:41 AM
Once up on a time I found a bad LX bolt , the problem was the hole thru the center of the bolt was not drilled all the way down to intersect with the side vent hole , Does it vent when it hits the ball ?

I will defiantly check that... although half way through this i switched to my other lvl 10 bolt...


Are you using the largest carrier before it leaks down the barrel with out shooting?

I sure am. i just switched to a lower one as i was starting to leak


Id agree with the carrier size... my bolt sits so loose I expect it to leak every time I air it up, but it doesnt.

does the lvl 10 work on something other than paint? say for instance your tongue :rofl:

No but really, how hard of a "hit" does the bolt give a swab thats a little bit away from the bolt face? I can just stuff the swab down the barrel up to the bolt face in mine and shoot and it takes 5-6 shots to even move it enough to do a full fire.

it is hitting a little harder then I would like. I cant figure it out.


If you are making sure the ball is in the breach when firing, then it isn't chopping, which is what the level 10 is designed to prevent. It sounds like it is breaking balls when firing, which is a totally different problem. The bolt is getting up to full speed and force when you are getting your breaks, which indicates that it may be barrel related.

Ball breaks other than chops are caused by different scenarios such as:

1) the ball rolling forward too far which allows the bolt to slam into it at full force
2) the barrel being too tight for the paint being used
3) a detent sticking too far into the breach or perhaps broken and tearing the ball

How brittle is your paint? How large or small is your paint? Is it small enough to fit the barrel without any force?

refer to this video as to how im testing. @0.40 seconds


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57nMmXLmTVo


I've also heard of issues where people who don't have the goalie on there bolt where paint is rolling back a bit and the next ball comes partially in the breach. With the force of the hopper it may be to much causing the ball to break.

Im not using a hopper, 1 ball at a time.

goalie?:confused:
http://www.forsportsmaryland.com/images/goalie-pic.jpg

captian pinky
04-13-2013, 12:01 PM
i would start by changing your oring in the carrier.
starting with the largest carrier if it leaks upon airing it up move down until it no longer leaks.
use the red spring with the eff. insert, if not i would use the long spring.

are you using a ult or rt on/off?

BTAutoMag
04-13-2013, 01:11 PM
i would start by changing your oring in the carrier.
starting with the largest carrier if it leaks upon airing it up move down until it no longer leaks.


why would I break with 2 different valves with 2 different lvl 10 kits? as stated


use the red spring with the eff. insert, if not i would use the long spring.

Ive tried the long spring... as stated. and i cant find my red spring... as stated


are you using a ult or rt on/off?

ULT... as stated

captian pinky
04-13-2013, 01:29 PM
im trying to help you narrow it down to one possibility.

pull your detents out
if you have a rt on/off i would use that to tune your lvl10.
long spring
change the oring in the carrier to a brand new oring

do you have a rail bushing?
were you shooting hot?
is your bolt smooth?( aka nicks or burs from hitting the detents)
have you tried differnt paint?

BTAutoMag
04-13-2013, 02:56 PM
pull your detents out

tried it



if you have a rt on/off i would use that to tune your lvl10.


tried it


long spring

tried it



change the oring in the carrier to a brand new oring


tried 2 different ones



do you have a rail bushing?


even tried 2 rails



were you shooting hot?


going to borrow chrono today



is your bolt smooth?( aka nicks or burs from hitting the detents)


yes



have you tried differnt paint?

nope. only paint I have access to unless I goto walmart and get theirs:nono:

blackdeath1k
04-13-2013, 04:13 PM
At this point either shooting hot or a bad batch of paint come to mind.

BTAutoMag
04-13-2013, 07:01 PM
ok, took my lvl 10 apart and replaced the oring... went up 4 sizes. then installed the long spring. i got a chrono and tuned in around 270ish. got some wallmart stinger paint and let it rip for a hopper...

broke 4 balls:mad:

took my barrel off and they broke in the last inch of the barrel and put a very long scratch down the side of my bob long assasin 14" barrel. :mad: but no breach breaks:cool:

so I shelved the other 300 balls of the stinger and loaded up with graffiti...

no breaks through 3 hoppers. still not sure if everything tuned with the lvl 10 well or not as its hitting the squeegee to hard for my liking but im sick of cleaning a soupy breach so im not gonna try a half load test. I am going to play with it tomorrow. conditions are spose to to be 40s with a chance of rain. I'll be reffing most of the day though so i just wont play when its raining:rofl:

everyone cross your fingers

BTAutoMag
04-14-2013, 05:26 PM
well I left my wallet at home an it was miserable out today so I didnt play with my gun...

but one of my buds from the local semi pro team was oogling over it... so he played with it. he did have some complaints about it which I will list:

-It was 35* out and lukes frame absorbed all of that:rolleyes:
-My mag is too small and compact for him:rolleyes:
-The trigger is too touchy:rofl:

oh, and he's never seen a mech out shoot shoot a prophecy but no broken paint. apperently we switched from graffiti cause its retarded and made in Taiwan. We shoot an Empire custom blend that my mag loves!