is it possible to burst a burst disk on a co2 tank from a bad fill? my bud has always come to me to get his tanks filled (i have a fill station) and we have never had a problem. But i was away one weekend so he went to the field and had them filled both of the burst disks burst that day. so he replaced them and came to me the next weekend and i filled them and had no problem, so he is playing at the field that he had them filled before and ran out. so they fill it and they both burst again. so of cource he got new ones and we have been playing for weeks and i have been filling them and have had no problem. and once again he takes them to the place to get them filled and they go like a day or 2 later. should he go back and get a refund? or is it luck of the draw? should he be using locktite or teflon tape on it or what do you think is going on
-
-
They are probably getting overfilled or storing them where they are getting to hot ... living in florida i never would fill my bottles all the way full if i wasnt going to play that day it was just asking to blow a burst disk. -
Comment
-
An alternate use for burst disks:
I have one threaded into the side port of my Mag's vertical ASA, which I bypassed. I may one day replace it with a gauge to make all the agglets' heads explode as they think I bypassed my LP reg and am running a marker at full regulator pressure.Comment
-
Since your discs were relatively new, they should not have been fatigued. Unless the whole assembly popped out, the only issue for loctite would be to plug up the disc, which didn't happen.
I vote for the 1.8k disc and the booster combo.
I had a guy fill a bottle for me with a booster (the little two cylinder gizmo in the fill line) and no scale. When I weighed it, it was heavy. I vented it off and fortunately didn't need to go back.
The surest and one of the most exciting ways to blow a disc is to leave the bottle on the dash board of a car with the windows rolled up in the sun. Be sure and let some fresh air in before you enter.
The odd thing is that a CO2 bottle will put out a relatively steady pressure of about 750 psi from full capacity to the last bit of liquid as long as it can pick up enough heat. As long as you have some vapor space in the bottle, it should be able to re-liquify at a given pressure and temperature. To blow a disc you have to 1) fill the bottle completely with liquid or 2) apply too much heat or 3) fatigue the disc.
I wonder if the way those boosters pump gas into the bottle isn't a little hard on the burst discs. Basically applying many more pressure cycles to the disc than the fill-dump-fill method.Comment
-
alright i know im going to get flamed but i never use a scale in fact i know im over filling them when i do them, Ive never had a problem and neither have my couisns (who were playing when mags first came out, both have level 5s and some of the first minimags made) they went semi pro and they did the same as me also all the other teams did too.
my chemesty/physics may be a bit off, but in theory if its a liquid, full is full and no matter what a tank will be around 750psi if there is a small space or if there is a lot of space in the tank, so its always under the same pressure
by the way all the disks were 3000psi onesComment
-
I agree with Farmer. I have been filling my own CO2 tanks for ~10-12 years with 20lb tanks, and while I did have a scale at first I have found that I can watch how full a CO2 tank is visually.
Chill it real good, and then when you fill it you can hear and watch it fill up. I usually stop it ~ an inch from the top. Its probally wrong, but to date I have never had a burst disk blow on me.Comment
-
yeah im thinking that that could be the problem at the field. i chill the tank and watch it but i dont think ive ever seen them do it at the fieldOriginally posted by MANNComment
Comment