Has any ever tried to make a Titanium bolt for the Automag?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MAGslinger
    Get the SAWWW!
    • Mar 2008
    • 192

    #1

    Has any ever tried to make a Titanium bolt for the Automag?

    Just think of how much more gas-efficent (and faster) a RT or X-Valve would be if there were a titanium bolt you could buy for your automag? Has any ever attempted to market something like that?
  • mr.mag218
    just plain registered

    • Jan 2005
    • 577

    #2
    Originally posted by MAGslinger
    Just think of how much more gas-efficent (and faster) a RT or X-Valve would be if there were a titanium bolt you could buy for your automag? Has any ever attempted to market something like that?
    how would the exact same bolt design made of different material make it more gas efficiant?

    Comment

    • BigEvil
      www.BigEvilOnline.com

      • Feb 2005
      • 9333

      #3
      The ptp lvl 7 venturi bolt was either Ti or Ti nitride plated.

      The material and weight of the bolt isnt really the issue when it comes to gas mileage.

      Comment

      • ElPanda
        Polarstar E. and M.

        • Jan 2008
        • 495

        #4
        I remember reading one of TK's posts discussing why he never really made anything out of titanium, cause it was expensive, more difficult to machine, and only had benefits if you used less of it.

        I remember he made a batch of valves out of Ti to see if there was any differnce (they were heavier) and they got mixed in with normal valves, so somewhere out there are Ti valves that nobody knows about, he wanted one for his collection if I recall correctly.
        CNC Programmer/Machinist
        Polarstar Engineering and Machine

        Comment

        • snoopay700
          Serious About Men

          • Jan 2006
          • 3071

          #5
          Originally posted by ElPanda
          I remember reading one of TK's posts discussing why he never really made anything out of titanium, cause it was expensive, more difficult to machine, and only had benefits if you used less of it.

          I remember he made a batch of valves out of Ti to see if there was any differnce (they were heavier) and they got mixed in with normal valves, so somewhere out there are Ti valves that nobody knows about, he wanted one for his collection if I recall correctly.
          I thought they ended up weighing the same. Hmm, i'm going to have to try to find that thread and resolve this.

          But yeah, as for saving weight, you're probably not going to find a lighter and stronger bolt than the level 10.
          Il n'y a point de sots si incommodes que ceux qui ont de l'esprit.

          Comment

          • MoeMag
            Still here.
            • Dec 2005
            • 1821

            #6
            Isnt the stem inside the bolt welded in... Good luck doing that with Ti.

            Comment

            • ajnin
              Registered User
              • Oct 2006
              • 508

              #7
              ti eats tools.

              Comment

              • Raven001
                Registered User
                • Apr 2004
                • 314

                #8
                Originally posted by MAGslinger
                Just think of how much more gas-efficent (and faster) a RT or X-Valve would be if there were a titanium bolt you could buy for your automag? Has any ever attempted to market something like that?
                Around 94-95, Venom Toxic Toys or some one like that made what was claimed to be a Ti bolt for the Mag. It certainly was light and did help the rate of fire somewhat. It was too light and it wore out really quickly from rubbing against the spring and where the sear held the bolt. Don't remember it making any difference to the amount of air used.

                Comment

                • michbich
                  machinist-biochemist
                  • Jul 2007
                  • 849

                  #9
                  There wasn't much diference in weight between the Ti and SS valves. The reason was: Ti weighs colse to SS, but is stronger. So you would need less of Ti in weight to equal the strenght of SS. Unfortunatly, they couldn't change the size of the valve for obvious reasons so the weight were pretty close.

                  Here is the Ti valve thread:

                  Paintball Talk is the main forum for Automags.org. Here is where we talk about the sport of paintball in general and make announcements relating to the forum and website.

                  Comment

                  • egb groupie
                    Registered User
                    • Aug 2005
                    • 158

                    #10
                    I wonder why no one has ever tried to do a spring kit for the Mag, similar to to what NDZ did for the Invert Mini. Worked pretty good for them...

                    Comment

                    • trevorjk
                      <S>WooLooLoo</S>
                      • Dec 2002
                      • 4324

                      #11
                      Originally posted by egb groupie
                      I wonder why no one has ever tried to do a spring kit for the Mag, similar to to what NDZ did for the Invert Mini. Worked pretty good for them...
                      level 10
                      t33kyboy "So if a cat is dropped from 11 inches, it will most likely die."

                      Comment

                      • ElPanda
                        Polarstar E. and M.

                        • Jan 2008
                        • 495

                        #12
                        oh it was lighter not heavier
                        CNC Programmer/Machinist
                        Polarstar Engineering and Machine

                        Comment

                        • snoopay700
                          Serious About Men

                          • Jan 2006
                          • 3071

                          #13
                          Originally posted by ElPanda
                          oh it was lighter not heavier
                          Ok, that's what i thought, i thought it was either the same or the weight savings were marginal.
                          Il n'y a point de sots si incommodes que ceux qui ont de l'esprit.

                          Comment

                          • ajnin
                            Registered User
                            • Oct 2006
                            • 508

                            #14
                            titanium is a lot more brittle as well.. seems in an application like a constanly moving bolt that is slamming into other parts, brittle wouldnt be so great.

                            Comment

                            • egb groupie
                              Registered User
                              • Aug 2005
                              • 158

                              #15
                              Originally posted by trevorjk
                              level 10
                              I was meaning more like adjusting the actual strength of the springs, versus the lvl 10 springs which are basically all the same spring, just in various lengths. Could be interesting experimenting with the lvl 7 bolt.

                              Comment

                              Working...