Gonna share a bit of an email I sent....

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • punkncat
    One foot less
    • Feb 2003
    • 5841

    #1

    Gonna share a bit of an email I sent....

    I edited this for names and such...my experiance at a scenario this weekend. I left early.




    There were several issues that went on at this game that seriously have me considering attending a game at DELETED again. Actually to the point of recommending against doing so to anyone I know.

    During one point of the game, myself with a team member and several other players who were unknown to us advanced on a hot position and drove back a group of resistance. During the onsuing battle for that position ( locale 17 as i understand) we piled up behind the earth berm that is right next to the pvc canopy. The action was intense. Many players were quickly coming and going. The opposing team made a push and were able to overtake our position. One player topped the berm pointing at a teammate of mine yelling "take the hit"(surrender). I fired on and hit him, and proceeded to shoot two more of his teammates before the 4th player shot me and my teammate (who had chosen to surrender) several times. He was about 30 feet from us and made me and my teammate bleed. Him all the way through 2 layers of clothing.
    After we called out and walked a few feet out of the way I turned and asked the ref to chrono the person who had shot us. He told us to go back to our base and explain the situation there. I questioned this and mentioned that he, the player, and a chrono could be here now to deal with the situation. He again told me to return to my base and handle it there. I did mention it and a call went out to chrono all players at area 17. As we well know the offending player could easily have been far away by that time. I was asked if I could identify the player, which could have happened on the spot , but not later.

    Later in the day I was coming back into a game, went to my base to be re-inserted. We had a few minutes before reopening and a large group of players had collected around the base waiting to be reinserted. During this time the opposing team had made a push across the field and was surrounding the base in large numbers. We were standing around the base waiting for reinsertion while the other team is builing up and camping on our reinsertion point. We started taking balls a good 30+ seconds before we were even live again. Referees were calling us out as hit and we weren't even back in the game. So when the time did come, instantly we were rained on like fish in a barrel. The other team had built up to the point that we had no chance. Soon they assaulted all the way to the base and I was faced with another surrender situation. One player wrapped the corner and was yelling surrender on a group of 10+ players. I shot his hopper and he came around the builing yelling at me that I was supposed to surrender. I will come back to that subject. We worked out the argument between ourselves. It was a high adrenaline moment and thngs like that are bound to happen.

    This surrender rule needs to be either one way or the other. You can't suggest that someone surrender and expect not to get lit up. Especially when its one asking 10. As your rules outline you can ask for surrender, but can still be shot. Of the two times that I was asked to surrender it WAS within 10-15 feet. There were well more than two people involved. BOTH times there was confrontation afterward about why I didn't surrender. The ref referred to earlier dealt with that player, overlooking the bigger safety issue of a hot marker, to tell us to return to base. The second time I got two markers pointed at my head from 3 feet away.

    Aside from all other issues, your rules allow for me to refuse surrender. With that understanding how can someone be pissed when they ask for a surrender and get eliminated for it?

    To the point and the reason for the previous backstory. EVERY venue I have ever played allowed for hot insertion, OR made rules concerning camping on a reinsertion point. IIRC and something that DELETED should be able to back up, the DELETED got in trouble in years past for camping on reinsertion. I figure that that experiance alone would have had some affect on the consideration of making a rule of procedure for this.

    I didn't pay to play a game at your venue to be shot to hell and back within 3 feet of my reinsertion point. I went in and waited the allotted time to be put back in the game, get eliminated right away, but I am supposed to wait another 15 mins and have it happen again? The other team never even left the area.
    Making suggestions about surrender policy thats one thing. It is important, but that coupled with this incidence of camping on the insertion almost led to me getting shot in the face by two players at point blank range. There is no reason whatsoever that should not allow me a reasonable chance to safely reinsert into the game. I payed to play the game, give me the chance.

    I would appreciate a response on this matter, and to know what if anything will be done to resolve this problem in the future.
  • behemoth
    SVSTC?
    • Nov 2002
    • 7750

    #2
    Its people that dont care enough, such as the ref who wouldnt chrono the player in question that make me sick.

    But hey, it happens, we all hear sob stories, and we hear the ref's side (paging lohman)

    Goodluck with dealing with the feild.

    Comment

    • Lenny
      I AM the AO famous!
      • Dec 2003
      • 1628

      #3
      Good use of the English diction. That sounded very good and was easy to read.

      It should get things moving.
      Autocockers are the greatest markers ever made.
      ~The greatest BACKUP markers to AUTOMAGS!!

      Only temporary, get'n a new sig soon.

      Comment

      • Pump Scout
        Aging gracefully
        • Jun 2003
        • 141

        #4
        I almost hate to bring this up, but this is exactly why I shy away from most scenario games. In spite of what a certain segment of players claim, some venues of woodsball/scenario ball are NOT the haven for honor in this game that they think they are. At least in a tournament environment, you're more likely to have people watching you, be it refs, other teams, or just the casual observing audience. With a bigger game, you're far more likely to be well out of the observation area of the too-few refs (and the even fewer refs who actually care) to be able to be really helped by them. No tournament-typical marker is going to "feature" an easy-adjust velocity knob, or "Dial-A-Welt", as we used to call them. Rules tend to be similar from one game to the next, instead of "well, for this segment of today, we have this special rule, but since 20% of the players are getting food, 20% are getting air and paint, and 20% are waiting to use the Port-A-John, you 40% are the only ones who will hear this". There are way too many opportunities for a scenario player of weak morals to bend/break the rules and not only get away with it, but profit in the game from it.

        Very well written e-mail, sir. I hope you get some sort of results... but unfortunately, I wouldn't hold my breath. Seems a lot of places think they don't have to answer to the lowly player anymore.
        Ben Kohnen, Limited Pump Paintball
        www.geocities.com/limitedpump

        Comment

        • dahoeb
          Registered User

          • Jul 2004
          • 862

          #5
          Originally posted by Pump Scout
          In spite of what a certain segment of players claim, some venues of woodsball/scenario ball are NOT the haven for honor in this game that they think they are. At least in a tournament environment, you're more likely to have people watching you, be it refs, other teams, or just the casual observing audience.
          The sad thing is, in tourneys, even with all those people watching, theres still more cheating. Thats why they need to have so many refs on such a small field in the first place. And the casually watching audience never stopped a pro team from whiping a hit; watch any video of a tourney and you'll clearly see people whiping and or just ignoring hits all together. And tourney players don't have an easy to adjust velocity knobs n stuff, instead they "dial an overshooting" (yeah that was lame, sorry) into their cheater board before the game. In scenarios, it doesn't really matter if you get shot out, you just go and wait for reinsertion.

          Theres cheating in all aspects of the game, but scenario is probably the one with it the least, IMO.

          Anyways, good letter, Punkncat, very cool headed and professional. hopefully the field managers will act the same.
          Last edited by dahoeb; 11-19-2006, 12:37 PM.

          Comment

          • CrimsonGhost
            Distracted

            • Jan 2004
            • 478

            #6
            Originally posted by Pump Scout
            I almost hate to bring this up, but this is exactly why I shy away from most scenario games. In spite of what a certain segment of players claim, some venues of woodsball/scenario ball are NOT the haven for honor in this game that they think they are. At least in a tournament environment, you're more likely to have people watching you, be it refs, other teams, or just the casual observing audience. With a bigger game, you're far more likely to be well out of the observation area of the too-few refs (and the even fewer refs who actually care) to be able to be really helped by them. No tournament-typical marker is going to "feature" an easy-adjust velocity knob, or "Dial-A-Welt", as we used to call them. Rules tend to be similar from one game to the next, instead of "well, for this segment of today, we have this special rule, but since 20% of the players are getting food, 20% are getting air and paint, and 20% are waiting to use the Port-A-John, you 40% are the only ones who will hear this". There are way too many opportunities for a scenario player of weak morals to bend/break the rules and not only get away with it, but profit in the game from it.

            Very well written e-mail, sir. I hope you get some sort of results... but unfortunately, I wouldn't hold my breath. Seems a lot of places think they don't have to answer to the lowly player anymore.
            To PBN it a bit.. "QFT"

            Cheating is all over the place...Tour,Rec,Renegade. I do not think any one "style" of play cheats any more than another...so to me, saying one type is more prone to cheating than another is silly.
            If there is something to be gained , $$, prizes, bragging rights etc. There will ALWAYS be somone willing to cheat, push rules etc. to "win"
            It isn't exclusinve only to the Tour...I have seen more cheating and such in Big games in 4 hours than in 20 matches in Tour play.
            But I DO NOT think it is more pervasive in either.

            Sadly we have broken it down to something like this , " Would you rather be called a winner and go home with the prom queen OR be called honorable and go home to be able to look yourself every day?"
            They SHOULD go hand in hand but we put such a premium on winning that it takes priority over honor now.

            Material gain over moral... It is a choice.
            " Remember what the door mouse said..."

            Comment

            • SR_matt
              Santa Sucks
              • Jun 2006
              • 1072

              #7
              well the reff telling you to go back to your base to deal with the matter of the hot gun is retarded.

              the guy getting shot that had already surrendered, well yes he surrendered to prevent getting shot but if he is in an area that has live players close by as an opposing player comes in hes probably gona get shot, is it right? no, is the opposing player at fault, maybe but your friend could be just as at fault.

              now surrender rules are suggestions and only suggestions. if you want to give some one a chance to give up if you feel like being nice.

              getting lit up before you insert if bs but most producers and filed that do scenarios go by if you are with in 30 feet of the base it becomes hot but as long as they are at least 30 feet it is a standard insertion.

              i see why you are upset but IMHO the most of the issues you had where you feel rules were not enforced properly when from the rules i normaly experance they were enforced perfectly fine (with teh exception being of the player not being chronoed on site)

              -matt

              Comment

              • Paint-Fool
                Registered User
                • Sep 2003
                • 398

                #8
                Originally posted by punkncat
                I edited this for names and such...my experiance at a scenario this weekend. I left early.
                Even though you deleted the name of the field I know what it is by the berm/canopy description. I was there the whole weekend. Not sticking up for the field in any way..but the reffing has gotten better. It was alot worse last year and earlier this year. As you experienced it still has a long way to go. All the refs are supposed to have hand held chronos and he should have used it on the spot. Also the surrender thing is an option...you have the right to shoot. They have stated in every player briefing that you may get shot when you ask someone to surrender so don't get mad if it happens but of course many players don't pay attention to the briefings. Also they are supposed to move the reinsertion point if the base is hot...that was the refs fault not the field/scenario promoters. Unfortunately all the refs don't care about doin the right thing or they are incompetent or both.

                Comment

                • jenarelJAM
                  Club Coordinator
                  • Dec 2004
                  • 1611

                  #9
                  Okay, I used to ref. I used to ref on a muddy woodsball field on a hill. I used to be running up and down that hill, slipping, so I could check people. The ref with the chrono is an idiot. I routinely checked markers I thought might be hot, and I always checked markers that some other player thought were hot. There is no reason not to. Even laziness. I'm a pretty lazy guy. That guy must have gotten up in the morning wanting to roll over dead. I just don't get it. That's what I have the most of a problem with.

                  The other issues, I don't have so much experience with, because I've never played a scenario game before. Generally, even on our woodsball field, it was two team elimination. We had capture the flag, but meh, I don't care about capturing some flag, I just want to shoot people.
                  Basicly they seem like a lack of control of the field by the refs and owner. I don't know how many people were there, but the refs probably just didn't feel up to the task of trying to announce to all of them that the game was going to be adjusted because the safeguards that should have been put in play, weren't.
                  Anyways, I'm fully behind you in this. Bad reffing is one of the things I hate most about paintball.
                  you know you play this game too much when the neighbors stop fixing their broken windows...
                  :shooting: :cuss:

                  Comment

                  • master_alexander
                    im a gun pimp :D
                    • Sep 2004
                    • 2462

                    #10
                    so paintball is a sport. sports have rules, referees, and the rules do get bent and broken, while others stay in place no matter what. This thread did touch on cheating a bit, and my view is that all sports have some form of cheating or unsportsmanlike conduct in them, and here its wiping, ramping, and hot guns. and there are solutions to all of thoes, but none of thoes solutions solve the problems beforehand. and there really isint anything you can do about it. As for the ref not checking the supposed hot gun (probably was very hot if given the hits described) that is just horrible. i have some reffing expierence as well, and always walked the person who got shot and the person with the hot gun to the chrono, gun in my hand and resolve the matter. a quarter of the time it was weather or something making the gun range from 250 to 270 to 310, another quarter it was hot regardless, and the last half they were just hit in a crucial place or cant take the pain.

                    that is a very well written letter (whatever that means to you coming from a 16 year old, lol..) but i hope you get the matter resolved and all turns out well.
                    "Ah yes, I have one of the 32*rebels that I always take to big scenario games. It keeps the truck from rolling if I have to park on a hill." - automikey

                    Comment

                    • Skeeter
                      PBC Owner
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 121

                      #11
                      Any reff refusing to chrono a player in that situation needs to be brought to the attention of the head ref, or the field owner. They can't fix it, if they don't know it is broken. No excuse for that sort of behavior.

                      Others have covered the surrender situation accordingly.
                      Time is what keeps things from happening all at once

                      Comment

                      • indecisive
                        Registered User
                        • Nov 2006
                        • 50

                        #12
                        yeah, hot guns are my main concern with "scenario" days.. got a nice lump on my head from the one I attended last October, one of the guys I came with had a pod shot through.( by this I mean the ball actually managed to exert enough energy break through the side of a new pod)

                        Comment

                        • ProblemKinder
                          Colossians 3:8
                          • Aug 2006
                          • 861

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Skeeter
                          Any reff refusing to chrono a player in that situation needs to be brought to the attention of the head ref, or the field owner. They can't fix it, if they don't know it is broken. No excuse for that sort of behavior.

                          Others have covered the surrender situation accordingly.
                          i agree completely. hey skeeter, do you own a field in charleston? I think I may have bought my mag from you.

                          Comment

                          Working...