Top 10 Baseball Players

[Johnny_Reb]

The top ten of baseball are listed here.

If anyone disagrees post who you think should be included or switched.

1.Babe Ruth
2.Ted Willaims
3.Roger Hornsby
4.Willie Mayes
5.Ty Cobb
6.Lou Gehrig
7.Hounus Wagner
8.Stan Musial
9.Hank Aaron
10.Mickey Mantle

[Kevmaster]

i guess pitchers dont count?

[Johnny_Reb]

i guess pitchers dont count?

I dont think a player who pitches every 5th day could.

[Kevmaster]

even though we all know that great pitching beats great hitting?

[Johnny_Reb]

even though we all know that great pitching beats great hitting?

Lol, who do you think should be put on? Cy Young, Walter Johnson.

even though we all know that great pitching beats great hitting?

True, but still pitchers dont play everyday.

[bunkermaster10]

Top Ten

I think Mickey Mantle should be moved up in the list and Hank Aaron also. Also I think Roger Maris (sp?) should be on that list also.

[bunkermaster10]

No

No Pudge Rodriguez should not be in the top ten IMO. Thats just bad. I think Barry Bonds should be in that list up pretty high actually. He is just the "MAN". I don't like him though but he's a great ball player.

[Kevmaster]

id put Walt Johnson on there...no doubt...Cy Young would be a close 11-12th

[Johnny_Reb]

Roger Maris

Nah Roger Maris wasnt good enough.

think Mickey Mantle should be moved up in the list

Mick was always hurt tho so he shouldnt be higher. Y'know he came within 18 inches of hitting a ball out of Yankee Stadium. Mickey also has the record for longest hit ball, 565 ft.

Ken Griffey Jr.

Rrrrright.

I think Barry Bonds should be in that list up pretty high actually. He is just the "MAN". I don't like him though but he's a great ball player.

Barry's in the top twenty. Hes good but hes not good enough for the top ten. His career avg. is only .296, not high enough to be up there.

id put Walt Johnson on there...no doubt...

Ya but who would he knock out. If I expanded the list to twenty id include him and Cy.

[beam]

Man, there are so many good players. I think there should be more contemporary players. Your list is all vintage.

[Johnny_Reb]

List of the best of the current players


1.Barry Bonds
2.A-Rod
3.Albert Pujols
4.Sammy Sosa
5.Dontrelle Willis
6.Roy Halladay
7.Mark Prior
8.Roger Clemens
9.Alfonso Soriano
10.Derek Jeter

[bunkermaster10]

active players

I think Albert Pujols should be number one in the top ten this YEAR . He's got the best bat in the league.

[bunkermaster10]

I also think John Smoltz should be in the top ten active players.

[bunkermaster10]

Heres a question, who do u guys think should be MVP?

[Johnny_Reb]

I also think John Smoltz should be in the top ten active players.

I was debating that one, but I decided to add another hitter to even it up.

Heres a question, who do u guys think should be MVP?

If the Cards make the playoffs, Pujols will.

NL MVP=Pujols
AL MVP= Carlos Beltran

AL Rookie of the Year=Hideki Matsui
NL Rookie of the Year=Dontrelle Willis