Am I in the wrong here?

[BTAutoMag]

I was on PBN and saw a revvy for sale in the BST, he had it listed for 25$ and he would handle fees and shipping. I pmmed him and offered 20$, pretty standard as I tend to think that prices are always haggle-able. He says no so I say Ill do the full 25$. he messages back with his paypal and that he'll ship today, so I send him the money, click back on PBN, reply sent, with my address.

I am at work for this so I click off the screen cause my machine stopped cutting and I set up for the next cut. hit go and click open PBN again, he sent me a message saying that he changed his mind about the sale and that someone wanted to pay more then my full price offer and that he was backing out of the sale.

I click off the screen thinking he would issue a refund and go back to work. he did issue me a refund and when that went thru, I went to leave feedback, I issued him neutral feedback as I was neither happy nor mad about the transaction...

I'll let you pick it up from here, I blurred his name... but if you really wanna know, his stuff shouldn't be hard to find


here are screens

[cougar20th]

I would have definatly left him bad feedback not nuetral. You and he made a deal. You finiished your part. He changed his mind and told you why. Because he is greedy.

[dodge3500]

He got off easy with a neutral one.I would have burned his little ass up over it.the deal was made and you paid up enough said.:-)

[blackdeath1k]

Well I got my hopper from you today. You didn't hlback out. Haha.

Seriously though. I would have walked away and left no feedback at all. BUT. Neutral feedback he should be happy with considering he flat told you he was backing out for said reason. I can't stand dealing with people like that. When all the dust settles I may wish I had asked more. But if I tell someone its there's till a given date. It will be there's waiting on payment till that day comes and has gone.

[BTAutoMag]

Justice is served. My negative feedback was removed. His neutral feedback remains.

*I have seen screen shots of the entire conversation between both of you regarding the sale. What you are saying simply is not true. You backed out of the deal after he already sent payment because you got a higher offer. If you do that then you are liable for negative feedback. You are lucky he only gave you neutral. Leaving him negative, or even neutral, in return is not appropriate at all.

[C_losjoker]

I don't think he should be able to have a mod change or take that off. And yeah he should be happy that you put neutral.

If you are looking for a revi I have one.

[BTAutoMag]

I always need revvys

[wetwrks]

negative feedback was due...you were generous leaving neutral feedback. His feedback for you was uncalled for.

[Cyco-Dude]

I was on PBN...

well, there's your problem.

[BTAutoMag]

Oh he responded to the moderator's decision by saying I was making it up.

[blackdeath1k]

Oh he responded to the moderator's decision by saying I was making it up.

Making up the screen captions?

What is he..... 12?

Although I'm sure that is possible. no sane person would go to that trouble over a 25 dollar item that they didn't get under legitamet reasons.

[Gadget]

I think you were entirely justified leaving neutral feedback - I'd have probably left negative. If he doesn't want bad feedback he shouldn't welch on an agreed deal, sucks to be him. Glad to see the PBN mods came down on your side.

[Frizzle Fry]

Good for you...

I'm about to deal with a guy I bought a barrel from in "good shape" but seems to have had a file taken to the tip

[BTAutoMag]

Ok...

after the mod responded and removed his negative feedback... he re-gave me feedback...

but this time it was neutral

from mod:

Leaving him negative, or even neutral, in return is not appropriate at all.

not only that but he is getting friends to post for him on his BST giving him good feedback on his thread

[BTAutoMag]

I kninda feel like sending the Army against him but that's wrong and he's probably just some rich kid who doesnt know any better