Episode III: Revenge of the Sith [Review]

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • NJPaint
    Pro Peace
    • Jan 2003
    • 2478

    #1

    Episode III: Revenge of the Sith [Review]

    Alright, here it goes. First a preface. As with Attack of the Clones, I was able to get into a pre-screening through one of the guys that I was good friends with in High School (he's a few years older than me) who now works for Lucas doing something in the computer graphics department (or something, not exactly sure). So May 5th I went and saw Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. I'm not really going to sensor this review, so if you don't want me to acidentally reveal anything, although I'll try not to, I'd recommend not reading further.








    ------------ Space Intentionally Left Blank -----------------







    Okay, here it goes. Overall, I would rank Sith after Empire, and Hope, but in front of Jedi and way infront of the other two, which I won't bother to name. I was a huge critic of the first two and will be the first to admit that my expectations weren't all that high going into the film. However, I was thoroughly impressed. Lets get the easy stuff out of the way first. The cinematics and computer graphics were absolutely amazing. Think about the space battle in Jedi and multiply it by 50. It is insane! Very very fun to watch. Here is the thing though. The good cinematics doesn't end with the battle scenes and the light-saber duels, which there are plenty of and are amazing in their own right. There is actual emotion in this movie, none of the pretty boy acting in the first two, that will not be named. It isn't the most moving film ever made, but its good. One scene that really sticks out is when Anakin goes back to the Jedi Temple and enters the children's room. You feel your stomach dropping ad feel the pain as if you were Yoda and could feel their pain. Even Christensen delivers a performance that I enjoyed. (I maintain that he is the single greatest flaw in AOTC (damn it, I named it)). The stage of the Clone Wars is set and is amazing. The thought of the entire galaxy at war and its representation in the movie is excellent. I will stop short of going into the nitty gritty of what I liked until the movie comes out, little things, one that I will mention, Palpatine's face/character for example, are what make the movie fun to watch and I don't want to ruin it for people.

    I guess nothing is perfect, so what I didn't like. Natalie Portman. Just didn't add to the film. I think that her character could have done a lot more and just didn't work. Part of the blame I lay on the screenplay/directors and the rest I lay on Portman herself, who as always looks amazing, but the acting was a bit lacking. Also, I wasn't overly impressed with General Grievous either. I had extremely high expectations of course, and I was disapointed.

    I guess thats all I'm going to say about this here . See ya'll in the theaters May 19th!
    Rooster "But such is the mentallity of the Arab people. Which is why as long as there are Arabs, there will be a terrorist problem."
    ^^^ known AO racists


    Contact Info
    AIM: holsamoht
    e-mail: [email protected]
    My Feedback
  • gimp
    Registered User
    • Jan 2001
    • 2368

    #2
    Awesome. I can't wait to see it. Natalie Portman's good looks will distract me if she doesn't act that well. I'm really excited to see General Greivous fight, I have really have high hopes as well. Maybe now I won't be as dissapointed. Either way, I'm psyched to go see it.


    Oh yeah. Your one lucky dude. I want to see it now!!!!!

    Comment

    • BD_Paintball
      UW-Whitewater Paintball
      • May 2003
      • 2268

      #3
      i cant wait till i see this movie, the fights should be very good. cant wait
      My Guns: chrome and black pump mag
      -black 2k sniper 2
      -32* vision imp with ups, ECS, reloader B
      -was'd imp w/ i-frame and all ups, warp feed
      -88/3000 and 48/3000 tanks

      AIM: Paintball1084

      my feedback

      Comment

      • Vex
        Superiorly Inferior
        • Jun 2001
        • 1871

        #4
        Originally posted by NJPaint
        Even Christensen delivers a performance that I enjoyed. (I maintain that he is the single greatest flaw in AOTC (damn it, I named it)).
        People give him hell for his portrayal of a "whiny, stuck-up brat" in AOTC, but he just acted the character exactly how Lucas told him to. If you read interviews with the cast, they say that Lucas tells them how he wants them to perform. He has his vision of how the scenes play out, and the actors give him exactly what he wants.
        I personally feel that the first two prequels do an extremely good job of building up the plot and emotion for ROTS.
        "Otaeri wa doko desu ka?"
        ------------
        --Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side, a dark side, and it holds the universe together.
        ------------
        Think you're ready, Grasshopper?
        www.ohioshaolin.com

        Comment

        • NJPaint
          Pro Peace
          • Jan 2003
          • 2478

          #5
          Originally posted by phazeshifter
          People give him hell for his portrayal of a "whiny, stuck-up brat" in AOTC, but he just acted the character exactly how Lucas told him to. If you read interviews with the cast, they say that Lucas tells them how he wants them to perform. He has his vision of how the scenes play out, and the actors give him exactly what he wants.
          I personally feel that the first two prequels do an extremely good job of building up the plot and emotion for ROTS.
          I don't fault him entirely for the two un-named movies. I don't know who is to blame. All I know is that he did not deliver the performance that I would expect from someone playing the leading roll in a huge film that you know is going to be huge.
          Rooster "But such is the mentallity of the Arab people. Which is why as long as there are Arabs, there will be a terrorist problem."
          ^^^ known AO racists


          Contact Info
          AIM: holsamoht
          e-mail: [email protected]
          My Feedback

          Comment

          Working...